Hello, data farmer! At Green Valley Farms, we need to gather information
about our crops, analyze it, and store it properly to make better farming decisions.
To do this, we use data integration techniques called ETL and ELT.
Farmer Ted, our farm manager, needs to understand the difference between these two approaches:
ETL (Extract, Transform, Load): The traditional approach where we clean and process our crop data before storing it in our data warehouse.
ELT (Extract, Load, Transform): A newer approach where we store all raw data first, then process it within the data warehouse.
In this activity, you’ll help Farmer Ted learn about both approaches by:
Arranging the correct steps for ETL and ELT processes
Understanding when to use each approach
Comparing their advantages and disadvantages
Let’s get our hands dirty and learn about data harvesting!
ETL: Extract, Transform, Load ๐ฑ
ETL is the traditional approach to data integration. Think of it like harvesting crops,
cleaning and processing them at the farmhouse, and then storing the prepared produce in the barn.
ETL Process Visualization
Extract
๐
Harvest raw data from fields
โก๏ธ
Transform
๐งน
Clean and process at farmhouse
โก๏ธ
Load
๐ซ
Store in data barn
Your task: Arrange the ETL process steps in the correct order by dragging them from the field to the sequence area.
Available Steps
ETL Process Sequence
ELT: Extract, Load, Transform ๐
ELT is a newer approach that takes advantage of modern data warehousing capabilities.
It’s like bringing all harvested crops directly to a high-tech barn that can sort, clean, and process everything on-site.
ELT Process Visualization
Extract
๐
Harvest raw data from fields
โก๏ธ
Load
๐ซ
Store all raw data in data barn
โก๏ธ
Transform
โ๏ธ
Process inside the data barn
Your task: Arrange the ELT process steps in the correct order by dragging them from the field to the sequence area.
Available Steps
ELT Process Sequence
Comparing ETL and ELT: Which to Choose? ๐ค
Now that you understand both ETL and ELT processes, let’s compare them to help Farmer Ted decide
which approach is best for different farm data scenarios.
ETL Overview
Data is extracted from source systems, transformed in a separate processing server,
and then loaded into the data warehouse in its final form.
ELT Overview
Data is extracted from source systems, loaded into the data warehouse in its raw form,
and then transformed inside the data warehouse itself.
Key Differences
ETL Advantages
Better for limited data warehouse resources
Good for small to medium data volumes
More mature and established process
Data privacy compliance (sensitive data handled before loading)
Works well with older systems
ELT Advantages
Faster loading of raw data
Better for big data scenarios
More flexible transformations after loading
Can transform data on-demand as needed
Leverages modern data warehouse capabilities
ETL Limitations
Slower overall process
Limited by processing server capacity
Less flexible if new transformations needed
Data transformations are predefined
ELT Limitations
Requires robust data warehouse with processing power
More storage needed for raw data
Potential security concerns with sensitive raw data
Can be more complex to manage
When to Use Each Approach
When to Use ETL
When working with legacy systems
When data privacy requires filtering sensitive information before storage
When your data warehouse has limited processing capabilities
When dealing with small to medium data volumes
When predefined, consistent transformations are needed
When to Use ELT
When working with big data volumes
When using modern cloud data warehouses
When flexibility for future analysis is important
When you need fast data ingestion
When different transformations might be needed for different analyses
Your task: Help Farmer Ted decide which approach (ETL or ELT) is better for different farm scenarios.
Great Job, Data Farmer! ๐๐ฑ๐
Excellent work! You’ve successfully learned the differences between ETL and ELT data integration processes.
Now Farmer Ted understands how to handle farm data more effectively!
Remember these key points:
ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) transforms data before loading it into the data warehouse – like cleaning and sorting crops at the farmhouse before storing them.
ELT (Extract, Load, Transform) loads raw data first, then transforms it within the data warehouse – like bringing all crops to a high-tech barn with built-in processing capabilities.
Both approaches have their place in modern data integration, depending on your specific needs, data volume, and infrastructure.
Just like farming, data management requires selecting the right tools and techniques for the job.
With your new knowledge of ETL and ELT, you’re ready to help Farmer Ted make the most of Green Valley Farm’s data!
